What are some of the strengths and weaknesses of the kalam. I have, over the years, been a keen objector to the kalam cosmological argument, an argument that apologists like william lane craig use. Therefore, the universe has a cause problems with the kalam cosmological argument. One approach to answering this question is the cosmological argument. Interpreting gods action in the world, edited by j.
Craig provides a broad assessment of the argument in lieu of recent developments in philosophy, mathematics, science and theology. Quotes tagged as kalamcosmologicalargument showing 12 of 2 shallow men believe in luck or in circumstance. They are the foundation that the rest of our beliefs are constructed upon. Causal premiss of the kalam argument barkers objection to the kalam argument kalam and multiple cosmic causes swinburne on the kalam cosmological argument hilbert and kalam j. Lately though, ive been in a few debates where they like to draw out the infamous kalam cosmological argument for anyone that is not familiar with it, it basically goes like this. Of the many ongoing debates to answer this question, william craig examines one of the most controversial proofs for the existence of god. Refutacion al argumento cosmologico kalam download as pdf file. Jul 30, 20 i can state that the kalam cosmological argument is about things popping into existence because this is the phrase dr craig uses, and a little later he makes it clear that he is referring to things beginning to exist from nothing. William lane craig has refined it to make it the cornerstone of his argument for the existence of the god of christianity. The clearly observed expansion of the universe as evidenced by red shifts leads to the hubbles law.
What is wrong with the first premise of kalam cosmological. Is there a good counter argument to the kalam cosmological. I the argument is valid, so to defend it one need only defend the two premises, and that the conclusion implies the existence of god i 1 seems intuitive. A summary of the problems with the kalam cosmological argument. Often our logical conclusions presuppose what is known as a basic belief. But since i was requested to answer, heres the first premise. William lane craigs kalam cosmological argument kca requires that an a theory of time is correct. A change in form is not the kind of beginning that the kalam argument is attempting to prove. The most simple criticism of the kalam cosmological. He rejects all four of the arguments drawn from metaphysics and physics for the second premiss that.
Os argumentos podem ser agrupados em tres tipos basicos. Metcalfe abstract william lane craig is the most recognizable contemporary defender of the kalam cosmological argument. There are two aspects of the kalam argument that especially make it different from st. Lewis the laws of physics, i understand, decree that when one billiards ball a sets another billiards ball b in motion, the momentum lost by. There is nothing so absurd that some philosopher will not say it cicero. Countering william craigs kalam cosmological argument by jonathan ms pearce did god create the universe from nothing. Mackies most potent blast against the rationality of belief in god, his the miracle of theism appeared after his death. Not all atheists are as capable of blind, willful ignorance as dawkins.
Prospect theory proposes that the reference dependence bias is firmly rooted in peoples minds, affirming that people rely heavily on a piece of relevant information while making decisions. To arrive at this conclusion, the argument employs facts concerning causation, cosmology, and contingency, as related to the beginning or coming into being of the universe. Oct 20, 2017 from our series entitled does god exist. Against the second premiss of the kalam cosmological argument, that the universe began to exist, j. Just over a year ago at richard dawkins site, someone asked dawkins to respond to the kalam cosmological argument see an exposition of the argument here. The kalam cosmological argument written not by curtis hrischuk but by some other fellow what follows is a short presentation of the kalam cosmological argument for the existence of god. Pearce provides the readers with a users guide on how to. May 07, 2014 the most simple criticism of the kalam cosmological argument by jonathan ms pearce may 7, 2014 64 comments listening to the reasonable doubts criticism of the dreadful sounding film gods not dead, justin schieber referred to a point made by wes morriston. The kalam cosmological argument for gods existence. A fallacy of cosmic proportions the kalam cosmological argument july 10, 2017 6 comments in philosophy by hugh harris a further response to gary robertsons is naturalism more probable than supernaturalism. What is wrong with the first premise of kalam cosmological argument. The results from the wmap probe give a good value for the hubble constant, and it would appear that we could extrapolate backward to the beginning of the universe, a process which yields.
When christians claim that jesus is the only way to god, an objection is often raised. When i say cite sources i am looking for more than wikipedia. The fact that the universe exists means that somebody must have created it in the first place, and this somebody is. More from animated videos what about people whove never heard of jesus. Argumento cosmologico kalam acima simplificado foi desenvolvido pelos filosofos arabes durante. I the other philosophical argument o ered in defense of premise 2 is that there cannot be an actual in nite in the world, merely a potential in nite. I just want to say that i am thus far, and ignorant theist who is illiterate in the areas of physics and math but i really desire to defend the kalam cosmological argument but i do not know where to start. The most simple criticism of the kalam cosmological argument by jonathan ms pearce may 7, 2014 64 comments listening to the reasonable doubts criticism of the dreadful sounding film gods not dead, justin schieber referred to a point made by wes morriston. What is the difference between the kalam cosmological. If jesus is the only way to god, what about those whove never heard of jesus. In fact, the argument does not assume any sort of beginning point, whereas mackie himself commits the fallacy of composition.
Mackie objects that the arguments for it either assume an infinitely distant beginning point or fail to understand the nature of infinity. William lane craig advances an argument for the existence of god in the kalam cosmological argument london. Kalam cosmological argument james still the clocks were functioning, thus someone must have set them in motion, even if their winding had been designed to last a long time. The universe began to exist therefore the universe has a cause of its existence. Kalam cosmologico argumento kalam cosmological argument. The kalam cosmological argument is a product of the tradition of islamic science known as ilm alkalam, which was established in order to defend the islamic faith against academic criticism. A defense of the kalam cosmological argument and the btheory. Introduction like david humes dialogues concerning natural religion, j. Professor mackie discusses the kalam cosmological argument. Paul draper, a critique of the kalam cosmological argument 1.
Graham oppy has emerged as one of the kalam cosmological arguments most formidable opponents. A solid rebuttal of the kalam cosmological argument. Brian pitts on the kalam cosmological argument morality and does god exist wes morriston on divine creation is god actually infinite. Sep 10, 2012 i have, over the years, been a keen objector to the kalam cosmological argument, an argument that apologists like william lane craig use to posit the existence of a creator god for the universe. A defense of the kalam cosmological argument and the btheory of time curtis j. The question of the metaphysical possibility of an infinite temporal series of finite duration 2004 arnold t. The kalam cosmological argument is a product of the tradition of islamic science known as ilm al kalam, which was established in order to defend the islamic faith against academic criticism. However it might be formulated, it depends on the conclusion that. What we call today the kalam cosmological argument, was first made by aristotle and then by islamic scholars in the 9th century. I do not have an example of something coming into existence from nothing without a cause. Is there a good counter argument to the kalam cosmological argument. Heres the kalamcosmological argument as rendered deductively by craig see included links for details.
What are some of the strengths and weaknesses of the kalam cosmological argument. The sources used in this presentation are documented according to current modern language association standards. A short, animated video to help you understand the kalam cosmological argument for gods existence. Revision outline for the cosmological argument ao1 a examine the key features of the cosmological argument for the existence of god. Graham oppys recent book arguing about gods has a thoughtful, challenging section dedicated to william lane craigs exposition of the kalam. It assumes the atheory of time, which is not obviously true. Sep 09, 2012 what we call today the kalam cosmological argument, was first made by aristotle and then by islamic scholars in the 9th century. Or is the material universe all that is, or ever was, or ever will be.
The kalam cosmological argument is essentially timebound. The success of the kalam cosmological argument in establishing an existence in god the kalam cosmological argument is an argument from the existence of the world or universe to the existence of god, i think this is effective because the existence of the universe, such arguments claim, stands in. In 2003, scientists arvind borde and alexander vilenkin and alan guth published a paper documenting that the universe cannot be infinitely old the universe is expanding. Traditionally these are questions for philosophy, but philosophy is dead stephen hawking. Oppy challenges craig on every step of the kalam, but im going to focus upon one. The kalam cosmological argument kca is standardly understood as being based upon the proposition that any infinite temporal series is metaphysically impossible. As craig explains, from start to finish, the kalam cosmological argument is predicated upon the atheory of time. Eternity and time in william lane craigs kalam cosmological. Everything that begins to exist has a cause of its existence. It was popularized by william lane craig in his book, the kalam cosmological argument 1979. This investigation tries to evaluate the cosmological demonstration on the existence of god by william l.
The first part aims to establish that there is a cause of the universe. A fallacy of cosmic proportions the kalam cosmological. Please show humility as this is a genuine question so no trolling. How to defend the kalam cosmological argument just like. Is the kalam cosmological argument a sound proof for god. A basic belief would be a belief that we cannot prove by any empirical means, but that we are all rational accept. The goal is not to offer a thorough defense or refutation of the argument in the original post, but to unpack it togeth. The most simple criticism of the kalam cosmological argument. A defense of the kalam cosmological argument and the b. Jul 10, 2017 a fallacy of cosmic proportions the kalam cosmological argument july 10, 2017 6 comments in philosophy by hugh harris a further response to gary robertsons is naturalism more probable than supernaturalism.
A couple weeks ago, we kicked off a new series of posts where well introduce one of todays most popular arguments for or against god, and then invite openended discussion. The kalam cosmological argument is an exercise in positive deist apology which aims to demonstrate that the existence of god can be inferred to be highly probable. On the kalam cosmological argument an earlier draft of the paper in facets of faith and science. The book is a broadside against not only the traditional arguments for gods existence, such as the onto, cosmo, and teleological. Every contingent being including things infinitely old has a cause of its existence b.
Mar 12, 2020 there are two aspects of the kalam argument that especially make it different from st. The argument, in its simplest form, is that i whatever begins to. Hey wk, i didnt read your post and i believe if i did i wouldnt be able to understand it. The fact that the universe exists means that somebody must have created it in the first place, and this somebody is most likely god. Im a very convinced atheist, and love to debate religion. I can state that the kalam cosmological argument is about things popping into existence because this is the phrase dr craig uses, and a little later he makes it clear that he is referring to things beginning to exist from nothing. The kalam cosmological argument hashtagapologetics. The kalam cosmological argument is a modern formulation of the cosmological argument for the existence of god. Craig, also know as the kalam cosmological argument, based on the temporal origin of the universe. The success of the kalam cosmological argument in establishing an existence in god the kalam cosmological argument is an argument from the existence of the world or universe to the existence of god, i think this is effective because the existence of the universe, such arguments claim, stands in need of explanation, the only adequate explanation, the arguments suggest, is.
1214 367 56 877 645 625 1258 1209 662 1434 304 1002 1000 1088 356 1400 801 438 925 1109 644 855 793 586 1017 903 290 112 1211 852 1594 867 895 796 852 925 589 1080 591 265 1075 659